How people understand government debt and the fiscal outlook

Fiscal Beliefs connects four questions: what people believe gives government debt its value, how much fiscal risk they perceive, when those beliefs enter decisions, and how the expected path of taxes, spending, deficits, and debt is changing.

Explore the findings

Selected findings

Government debt valuation

Safe-asset demand receives substantially more weight than future primary surpluses.

Safe-asset demand29.5

Future primary surpluses14.7

Average value points among bond investors under the benchmark reconstruction.

Explore the evidence Concern and action

Most concerned bond investors report no concrete portfolio adjustment.

72.0%

42.5% report no change and 29.5% describe monitoring or caution without reallocating.

Explore the evidence Randomized information treatment

Debt-to-GDP information significantly raises perceived ten-year debt-crisis risk.

Perceived ten-year crisis probability+14.9 pp

95% CI: +9.5 to +20.2 pp

Plan to reduce Treasury holdings+4.2 pp

Imprecise · 95% CI: −3.7 to +12.2 pp

Percentage-point treatment effects among bond investors; intended holdings refer to plans over the next 12 months.

Explore the evidence Fiscal expectations

Realized deficits usually exceed earlier projected paths.

89.8%

821 of 914 matched comparisons have a larger realized deficit than projected.

Explore the evidence